TY - JOUR
T1 - Management paradigms of persistent primitive trigeminal artery aneurysms
T2 - A systematic review and analysis of techniques and complications from 1960s to 2022: From conservative to surgical to endovascular, how far along the right path are we?
AU - Sreenivasan, Sanjeev
AU - Agarwal, Neha
AU - Roychowdhury, Sudipta
AU - Khandelwal, Priyank
AU - Sun, Hai
AU - Singla, Amit
AU - Sonig, Ashish
AU - Gupta, Gaurav
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2023.
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - Introduction: Aneurysms of persistent primitive trigeminal artery (PPTAAs) are increasingly reported and commonly managed by endovascular (EN) techniques. There are no systematic reviews or meta-analyses which analyse outcomes and complications of treatment modalities for PPTAAs. We aim to highlight the change in trend of management of PPTAAs and to identify clinical and radiological parameters which may influence management paradigms. Methodology: A systematic search of literature was done in PubMed, Embase, Google Scholar, Cochrane library and Medline using keywords ‘persistent primitive trigeminal artery’, ’aneurysms’, ‘embolization’, ‘surgical clipping’, etc. Only cases reporting aneurysms of PPTA were included. Three subgroups, such as conservative, open surgical (OS) and EN interventional, were studied for outcome evaluation. In the EN subgroup, relation of clinical and radiological parameters with outcome (complete/partial occlusion) was analysed using Microsoft Excel Data Analysis ToolPak. Results: Of the 101 articles found eligible for assessment, 54 were analysed quantitatively. Mortality in the conservative group was 12.5% and OS group was 9.09%. After EN treatment, complete angiographic occlusion was seen in 88.89% PPTAAs and 5.5% warranted retreatment. In the EN subgroup, location (p=0.17), shape (p=0.69), Saltzman circulation (p=0.26) or status of rupture (p=0.08) did not significantly impact angiographic occlusion outcome. Multivariate regression analysis showed 6.6% influence of independent variables, that is, age, gender, aneurysm location, side, shape (saccular/fusiform), rupture status and type of Saltzman circulation on aneurysm occlusion outcome [F(7,27) =1.34] (p=0.27). Total mortality reported in the EN group was 8.57%. Conclusion: Clinical or radiological parameters do not influence angiographic occlusion outcome. Although EN techniques are successful, meticulous reporting of outcomes and complications is important.
AB - Introduction: Aneurysms of persistent primitive trigeminal artery (PPTAAs) are increasingly reported and commonly managed by endovascular (EN) techniques. There are no systematic reviews or meta-analyses which analyse outcomes and complications of treatment modalities for PPTAAs. We aim to highlight the change in trend of management of PPTAAs and to identify clinical and radiological parameters which may influence management paradigms. Methodology: A systematic search of literature was done in PubMed, Embase, Google Scholar, Cochrane library and Medline using keywords ‘persistent primitive trigeminal artery’, ’aneurysms’, ‘embolization’, ‘surgical clipping’, etc. Only cases reporting aneurysms of PPTA were included. Three subgroups, such as conservative, open surgical (OS) and EN interventional, were studied for outcome evaluation. In the EN subgroup, relation of clinical and radiological parameters with outcome (complete/partial occlusion) was analysed using Microsoft Excel Data Analysis ToolPak. Results: Of the 101 articles found eligible for assessment, 54 were analysed quantitatively. Mortality in the conservative group was 12.5% and OS group was 9.09%. After EN treatment, complete angiographic occlusion was seen in 88.89% PPTAAs and 5.5% warranted retreatment. In the EN subgroup, location (p=0.17), shape (p=0.69), Saltzman circulation (p=0.26) or status of rupture (p=0.08) did not significantly impact angiographic occlusion outcome. Multivariate regression analysis showed 6.6% influence of independent variables, that is, age, gender, aneurysm location, side, shape (saccular/fusiform), rupture status and type of Saltzman circulation on aneurysm occlusion outcome [F(7,27) =1.34] (p=0.27). Total mortality reported in the EN group was 8.57%. Conclusion: Clinical or radiological parameters do not influence angiographic occlusion outcome. Although EN techniques are successful, meticulous reporting of outcomes and complications is important.
KW - Persistent primitive trigeminal artery
KW - aneurysm
KW - embolization
KW - subarachnoid hemorrhage
KW - surgical clipping
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85146084319&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85146084319&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1177/15910199221150471
DO - 10.1177/15910199221150471
M3 - Review article
C2 - 36617952
AN - SCOPUS:85146084319
SN - 1591-0199
JO - Interventional Neuroradiology
JF - Interventional Neuroradiology
ER -